Thursday, April 18, 2024

Survivor 46 Power Rankings Week Eight: Extra Credit

Well, whether you call it the +1 alliance or the “The Six” or Q’s crew, the big alliance that was hoping to run the game exploding spectacularly this week and, while I don’t think anyone was expecting that group to ride all the way to the end, it leaves a real gaping hole in the Survivor landscape. I’m definitely interested to see the fall out from this one and to try and laser in on who is a genius and who is just good TV. Was Q’s move at tribal council part of a next-level strategy or is he just a car crash you can’t look away from? Is Venus low-key a manipulator of this game or is she just that cringe type of humor that keeps you watching? Does Ben rock at this game or is he just nice? Is Liz “Cocky B” Wilcox about to steal a $1 million to add to her stash or is she just a person that is on TV? The lines are getting blurry and I honestly don’t know anymore.

 

10. Tevin (Orange) – Down Four

My wife has been on this for a few weeks now, pointing out Tevin’s rather villainous edit, and we see it come to fruition here when he gets caught completely napping in his vote out this episode. Didn’t really come close to sniffing out his blindside at any point during this game and in successive weeks voted out Soda, who though of him as one of her best allies, and then made Liz mad enough to turn on him by taking too much credit for voting out Soda. He also got way to invested in the six which, as some people out there could clearly see, was never a feasible way to make it to the end. Tev, your voice will be missed.

9. Q (Purple) – No Change

Outwit: 1 pt

Outlast: 1 pt

One week after I proclaimed that Q had his worst episode of the season, he comes back and says hold my rice. Keep in mind that this episode began with him throwing away social bonds and putting way too much emphasis on strategy and then later had him turning on his own #1 ally. That right there would have been problematic, but then he lost it at tribal and made literally everyone left in the game angry with him. The one thing I felt he had going for him was that, if he somehow got to the end, he could point to doing it despite being a big presence would drove a lot of votes and I think that jury would have respected it. Now, I don’t think there’s much respect (or trust) left for Q and that leaves him out of options. Maybe he will be a goat to bring to the end at this point, but that’s about the best he can hope for. Even Jelinsky had a better episode than Q because at least that man got yet another shout out for his legendary one-episode performance and maybe he will get to come back and play again one day.

8. Venus (Orange) – Up Two

I continue to have mixed feelings about the game Venus is playing. On the one hand, she is playing hard. She’s trying to make moves, she competes well in the challenges and, by the way, the two people that she has wanted to get out of this game got blindsided in back-to-back weeks. Unfortunately, no one on the island seems to respect her game at all and that is not a good sign for her jury chances because, at this point, I don’t really know how she can possibly shake that off, but at some point the fact that she continues to not get voted out and get the people she wants voted out will start to count for something right?

On the other hand, Venus seems to really lack self-awareness and while there are a ton of different personalities and skill sets that have won survivor, I feel like you absolutely need to have strong self awareness. Or at least the strongest self awareness of the other people sitting at final tribal so that you can make your case to the jury and get the majority of votes. So in that sense, she can probably only beat Q.

7. Liz (Orange) – Up One

Outwit +1

Look, I’ve got to give Liz a point here because she was the driver of this blindside and it is a resume point that she was in dire need of. No one was respecting Liz’s gameplay out there or in here. She’s quickly climbed up the ranks and is no longer among the bottom dwellers. There’s a ray of light where you can see her taking this thing. As much as it was encouraging to see her edit pick up this episode, I do think there could be some negative repercussions of her actions. For starters, she just voted out someone who was working with her and probably one of her closer allies (although, can you really tell with Liz?) and she further weakened Orange who, after losing two players in a row, could potentially continue to be a target next week (although I said the same thing about Green and now look at them). Plus, now Liz has a move and sometimes the tallest weed gets chopped or whatever the expression is. But hey, if you are a Liz fan you have to at least be encouraged that we have genuine gameplay to dissect here rather than just some joke about her looking like Moriah.

6. Hunter (Orange) – Down Four

Outplay: 4 pt

A few weeks back, I talked myself into Hunter as a contender, but I am waffling hard after watching this latest episode. The positive is that, while all alliances were crumbling, his name did not come up at all (yes, he was immune for half the time, but even before that he was seemingly a non-target). People don’t seem to be locked on him as an end game threat and I think that is an oversight. The problem for him now is that The Six has absolutely crumbled and that was the biggest source of his protection. To make matters worse, he lost his number one ally in Tevin. To make matters even worse, he lost Q as a shield because either Q is going quickly given that no one trusts him / they think he wants to quit or no one is going to even bother with Q because he has lost all credibility as a jury threat. Even though he won immunity this week, that could work against him too because it reminds everyone that this guy is a physical beast who could go on a run at the wrong time and steal this thing. He’s still got his idol, but he might need to play it as soon as next week to stay in this game.

5. Ben (Green) – Up Two

Outlast: 2 pt

I thought Ben was in big trouble this week and all he did was put his head in his shirt and it was impossible for anyone to target him. Ben has this way of being both social and likable but also so incredibly non-threatening that people don’t seem to be all that interested in using a vote on him. I just can’t get over the metaphor of him tying Hunter in hide and seek – they both accomplished the same thing: one by using super athleticism and flash to climb up into a tree and one by doing something that I would do when I run out of ideas playing with my niece. Is Ben a genius survivor player? I cannot decide. Even the rock puns are growing on me a little bit.

Eh, not that’s a lie, I still hate them.

4. Tiff (Purple) – Down Three

Outplay: 1 pt

Outlast: 1 pt

My top four here are sort of in their own tier at this point and it’s no coincidence that these are the two closest pairs in a game that just got flipped on its head. My previous number one Tiff slips down the rankings this week, much like she did in the Get a Grip challenge, because it’s really difficult to hold on when the margins are this thin. Tiff was a target this episode and, while she seemed to survive without much trouble, it wasn’t great for her that a) Q turned on her, b) she threw out Maria’s name and made an enemy of one of the other power players and c) her idol is either about to be or already is public knowledge. These are all things that I think she can pivot around, but her threat level is elevated and her numbers shrank so, in this wild landscape that is starting to take shape, Tiff is in at least some danger.

3. Maria (Green) – Up One

Outwit: 1 pt

Outplay: 1 pt

Outlast: 1 pt

I feel slightly better about the Charlie-Maria pairing and their connections than the Tiff-Kenzie duo so Maria gets the nod here at number three. However, Maria’s name also came up tonight and, while it never seemed to take hold, she is also trickling onto people’s radars as a threat. I was pretty encouraged by her episode this week and feel like she is built for a nice run to the end, however, I do feel like Charlie seems to be getting a lot more of the strategic confessionals and we are seeing things much more through his eyes. Is that a sign that he is getting the winner’s edit or just a sign that he is better at talking to the camera?

2. Kenzie (Purple) – Up One

Outlast: 2 pt

If you go back through my posts, I’ve never doubted Kenzie’s ability to make connections or her win equity, I’ve merely doubted her ability to camouflage. I think it is safe to say that she has mastered that part of the game and she has a pretty brilliant merge. If she hadn’t already, she has officially usurped Q to become Tiff’s #1 ally. She has a great connection with Ben which I think could be critical in the power vacuum that is left after the break-up of The Six. And, oh by the way, she wasn’t in The Six so it’s pretty great for her that it broke up. Meanwhile, Tiff and Q are the bigger threats. It’s 3-3-3 between Green, Purple and Orange so it’s time for the players to start looking at weakening Purple but with the public idol and Tiffany out ahead of her, Kenzie should hopefully be in a strong enough spot to weather the storm.

1. Charlie (Green) – Up Four

Outwit: 1 pt + 1

Outlast: 2 pt + 1

Yes, I’m doing it. Two points for Charlie tonight. I thought this was a monster episode for him. To me, he got an excellent edit. He got a lot of strategic confessionals, he narrated the break up of The Six from start to finish (after weaseling his way into The Six due to his social ability and sycophantism) and he did just enough in the challenge to show everyone he is a competitor without becoming overly threatening. No one seems to think he is a threat (which eventually becomes a problem, but that is a later problem) and a lot of people seem to really trust him. Tiff came to him at tribal and he reassured her in a way that probably bumps him ahead of Q. Liz seemed to spend a lot of time with Charlie and Maria trying to hatch this plan. We know Ben and Maria love him, dating back to his days on Siga (that’s the Green tribe – I’ve finally learned all the tribes names now). Even he and Venus seem to be on decent terms at this stage in the contest. I don’t know, maybe I’m a sucker for the edit, but this guy really felt like a winner tonight. Let’s find out if I’ve got it right.

No comments:

Post a Comment