Wednesday, May 1, 2024

Survivor 46 Power Rankings Week Ten: Eating Good In the Neighborhood

This episode was very fun. And its even more fun because I have no idea what is going to happen next. Probably whoever finds the rehidden idol will immediately be blindsided.

8. Tiffany (Purple) – Down Three

Outplay: 1 pt

Outlast: 1 pt

Another episode, another person that goes home with an idol in their pocket. That’s the third time it’s happened this season and, by the way, there’s still time for it to happen one more time. I feel like we have reached the point now that it’s clear you aren’t going to be able to “read” the other players in the game and deduce when to play the thing and if your idol is public knowledge this early, it incentivizes people even more to blindside you. Just a bummer because I really enjoyed Tiff. She probably will be a fun juror though.

7. Q (Purple) – Up One

Outwit: 1 pt

Outlast: 1 pt

At this point, I’m pretty sure the jury would rather give the $1 million to Jelinsky than give the money to Q. Not because they don’t want Q to have the money, but because they would never ever want him to feel validated that his strategy actually led to him winning. He’s a huge goat and he can probably ride that right into the end game, especially now that Maria has taken him under her wing as a personal extra vote.

Keeping all this in mind, is there any point where Q starts to get credit for what he’s doing? Maybe not in the eyes of the jury but perhaps in the eyes of the fans? He’s actually been playing super low key these last two episodes while sucking up all the attention of the people who are being blindsided. It would not have been possible to blindside two people with idols without him playing this pretty much perfectly. How much actual agency does he have? At this stage, very little – but the more threats that go out the closer he is to that coveted Venus-Liz-Q final three and then all bets are off.

6. Liz (Orange) – Up One

Outwit: 1 pt + 1

I’m giving Liz the Outwit point here for putting aside her hunger and her thirst for vengeance to make what I think was a smart move and blindside Tiff. Liz cannot beat many people in this game – you can argue she can’t beat anyone – but she has to like her odds against Q. Why waste a vote on him when you get out a real threat with an idol and challenge skills? However, I do not think Liz’s temper tantrum helped her win equity very much. Do I blame her for being upset that the one person who is not going to pick her to go on this reward won the challenge and subsequently did not pick her to go on the reward? Especially given that she is literally the world’s biggest Applebee’s fan? No, I do not blame her. But I don’t think it was a good look – particularly the part how she was mad at Q for blowing up her game. That part just seemed a little pouty to me and sort of undermines the seriousness/strategicness of her gameplay. Now that the show gifted her some rice, I am hoping she can get things under control because she still has at least some shot to win this thing as long as she can manage to be more likable than Q and Venus.

By the way, not a great a sign that Liz was real bad at making the fire this episode. Feels like that could have been foreshadowing for a loss in the firemaking challenge at the final four.

5. Venus (Orange) – Up One

I went back and forth about this one for Venus. On the one hand, I still think she’d be the favorite in a Q-Liz-Venus final three. I’d think she’d get Soda’s vote. I think she’d get Hunter’s vote. I think she’d get Tiff’s vote. I don’t think Liz would sweep the rest and I’m positive Q wouldn’t. So, she has that going for her. On the other hand, the Hunter-Tiffany blindsides back-to-back week combined with the continued goatification of Q has really thinned out the number of threats that are actually left in this game. Given how savvy Charlie, Maria and Kenzie have been so far, I am starting to think they may all look at each other and say, “hey, should we maybe start getting rid of some of these goats?” It has not once crossed their mind before so I wouldn’t say it’s likely, but the power players are making a risky move if they continue to go after each other and leave door open for the bottom dwellers to flip this on its head.

And, of course, Charlie and Maria went to Liz – who spent the entire last three days groaning about how much she is mad at Q and not sorry about it – over Venus to make the Tiffany blindside happen because they don’t trust Venus. They can at least work with Q and Liz, but Venus is very expendable. Plus, she could start to get aggressive/crazy with her gameplay after being on the wrong side of the vote for the first time all season. Certainly feels more likely than her calmly and quietly trying to reintegrate into the numbers.

4. Ben (Green) – No Change

Outlast: 2 pt

Ben is in a very weird spot. As you’ve probably noticed if you’ve been reading along with my rankings, I do not buy the narrative that Ben can win this game. I don’t really see his strategic chops and, although he is likable and a good guy, I don’t think he has the serious, cutthroat, mastermind vibe that all of these people obsessed with making big moves are going to turn around and give the title to. I also find it very difficult to see a scenario where he is at the end with Kenzie, Maria AND Charlie, seeing as those are his three biggest allies. Can’t imagine Ben beats any of them.

But obviously the jury would give it to him over Q, Venus and Liz so.

3. Kenzie (Purple) – No Change

Outlast: 2 pt

It is not often that a player benefits from being blindsided at tribal, but this whole Tiffany situation may have worked out OK for Kenzie. Sure, she doesn’t get the point for being the architect of the Tiff blindside, but she also doesn’t get the target that comes with voting her out either. She gets to have relatively little blood on her hands for this whole situation and there’s no way the fact that she floated Tiffany’s name last week can blow up her spot because Tiff is gone now. I’m pretty sure Tiff is a vote for Kenzie in the final 3 if she manages to get there. She’s definitely going to be vulnerable this next week, but if she can wriggle free of the vote, I think she has a really good chance at this thing. Hypothetically, if Maria or Charlie goes next week instead of her, I think there’s a very good chance the other one goes the next week (assuming no immunity wins or idol finds mess that up). A final 5 of Kenzie, Ben, Q, Venus and Liz would be super ideal for her – Ben is her #1 and I don’t think he would have the heart to backstab her and I have no faith that Venus, Q and Liz are going to suddenly team up against them.

That’s the ideal scenario for her, but how likely is that to happen really?

2. Maria (Green) – No Change

Outwit: 1 pt + 1

Outplay: 1 pt

Outlast: 1 pt

To me, this was Maria’s best episode of the season. I thought she was awesome in the first episode, but I hadn’t been super impressed with her gameplay since then. However, I really liked this episode for her. To me, she was clearly the architect of the Tiff blindside. She wanted to vote out Tiff for a while and she got her wish. She brought in Q. She brought in Liz. The way she pitched to both of them was brilliant too. She played perfectly on both of their egos in a way that honestly may help keep her threat level in check.

However, the big question for me heading into the next episode is: will Charlie and Maria both be able to survive? In theory, the other players will be able to deduce that they are the biggest threats to win this thing and the only strong pair remaining in the game and they will feel a need to break them up. And the real wildcard – will they turn on each other? There have been no signs of that at all and maybe in a season filled with people turning against their top allies these two will go all the way to the end together, but maybe they are just the last domino to fall. I think the final 7 is too early to turn on each other (as mentioned, if one goes next week, I think the other is likely to follow directly behind), but I could see a huge vote coming at the final 6. If Kenzie goes this week, what other threat is left to distract the bottom dwellers with?

1. Charlie (Green) – No Change

Outwit: 2 pt

Outplay: 1 pt

Outlast: 3 pt

You could certainly make the case that Charlie should be knocked off his perch this episode. He was more of a follower than a leader in the Tiff blindside. He has established himself as the biggest challenge threat remaining after a 2nd and two 1sts in successive match-ups. And I think losing Tiff was more costly for him than anyone else in the game because they had a good working relationship, she was a physical shield and she is most likely to feel burned by him than anyone else (besides Q of course).

But this may all work out OK for Charlie. Maria’s big move may be enough to distract people from the fact that he is a challenge beast and, if they take the shot at their pair, it may be Maria that they choose to go for. To steal directly from something a friend of mine said, Charlie is not seen as a leader and that probably works in his favor. I’m obviously super bias since I’ve been rooting hard for him since day one, but I just feel like he has a really good read on the game. He seems to be riding that line between building a resume and not becoming a threat. He has a good relationship with everyone but he is not such a bright, shining light of charisma that he can’t fade into the background when it suits him. And I love that he waited until his confessional to brag about all the grip strength workouts he’s been doing rather than doing some crazy gymnastics celebration in front of the rest of the cast Hunter-style. I am confident he is a good player. He might be this season’s Carson or this season’s Jesse. Or perhaps he could be the guy that finally slips through and wins it.  

No comments:

Post a Comment